Falls are increasingly recognized as a threat to the safety, health and well-being of people with multiple sclerosis (MS), and emerging evidence suggests that full time wheelchair and scooter users with MS have unique fall prevention needs. This review is comprised of three parts. Part 1 summarizes findings describing influences on falls among full time wheelchair and scooter users with MS and associated clinical implications. Although further studies are needed, early findings regarding influences on fall risk operating in this specific population highlight the importance of addressing falls that occur during activities of daily living, the high frequency of falls occurring in the bathroom, and both extrinsic (e.g., wet/slippery surfaces) and intrinsic (e.g., muscle spasticity/weakness) contributors to falls. Part 2 of this review describes available evidence regarding interventions to prevent falls in full time wheelchair and scooter users with MS. Because intervention work in this area is limited to one pilot study, Part 3 presents priorities for future research and identifies the need for randomized trials evaluating fall prevention programs that address diverse fall risk factors and allow for development and attainment of individualized fall prevention goals.
Accidental falls, multiple sclerosis, scooter, wheelchair
Laura A Rice, Libak Abou, Toni Van Denend, Elizabeth W Peterson, and Jacob J Sosnoff have nothing to disclose in relation to this article.
Double-blind peer review.
Compliance with Ethics : This article involves a review of the literature and did not involve any studies with human or animal subjects performed by any of the authors.
The named authors meet the International Committee of Medical Journal Editors (ICMJE) criteria for authorship of this manuscript, take responsibility for the integrity of the work as a whole, and have given final approval for the version to be published.
This article is published under the Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial License, which permits any non-commercial use, distribution, adaptation, and reproduction provided the original authors and source are given appropriate credit. © The Authors 2018.
July 10, 2018
Laura A Rice, 219 Freer Hall, 906 S. Goodwin Ave. Urbana, IL 61801, US. E: email@example.com
No funding was received in the publication of this article.
Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a chronic inflammatory demyelinating disease of the central nervous system and the most common non-traumatic cause of functional disability among young adults.1 Approximately 1 million people in the United States and 2.5 million worldwide live with MS.2 Although it is presumed to be an autoimmune disease caused by a variety of factors, the precise etiology remains unknown. The disease process associated with MS often leads to muscle weakness, spasticity, and sensory disturbances, as well as impairments such as gait dysfunction and impaired postural control.1 Approximately 25% of individuals living with MS are unable to ambulate functional distances in their home.3,4 For these individuals, wheeled mobility devices, such as manual wheelchairs, power wheelchairs, or scooters, are important to support functional mobility.
A recent study of 44 wheelchair and scooter users living with MS found that 75% of participants reported at least one fall in a 6-month period.5 The physical and psychological consequences of falls for persons with MS are increasingly well-documented5,6 and early evidence clearly suggests that fulltime wheelchair and scooter users are subjected to negative post-fall sequelae. Among the participants in the study described above, 76.7% (n=33/43) reported concerns about falling and 65.9% (n=29/44) limited their activities because of concerns. These findings, though based on a small sample, were surprisingly consistent with an earlier study that involved a cohort of 1,046 ambulatory and non-ambulatory individuals with MS.7 In that study, 63.5% reported fear of falling. Among participants reporting fear of falling, 82.6% reported activity curtailment.7 Activity curtailment associated with fear of falling is especially problematic due to its potential to contribute to physical deconditioning, increased fall risk,8,9 and potential negative impact on community-based activity. Community-based activity, which involves being active in family and community life and engaging in typical roles and responsibilities in society,10 is critically important to fulltime wheelchair users because it supports their health and well-being,11 and is strongly associated with quality of life.12 Among wheelchair users, being an active member of society is a key factor in preventing health deterioration.13
When a fall does occur, initial recovery, getting off the ground, and returning to a desired position, can be a challenge. Among older adults, long lie times (i.e., lying on the ground for longer than 1 hour) have been associated with serious injury, hospitalization, and a move to a long-term care facility.14 A study of ambulatory people with MS found that 27% of fallers lay on the ground for at least 10 minutes, and 4.6% experienced a long lie.15 A study of power wheelchair users with various disabilities, including MS, found that the majority of participants required assistance to recover from a fall and 15% lay on the ground for at least 10 minutes.16 While the research on post-fall experiences among wheelchair and scooter users with MS is not yet available, it is reasonable to consider that the documented consequences of a post-fall long lie may also be experienced by people with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users.
Due to the differences in physical characteristics (e.g., muscle strength and balance impairments) and functional mobility limitations (e.g., assistive devices utilized), risk factors for falls are most likely distinct for fulltime wheelchair or scooter users with MS compared to those who ambulate. Likewise, fall prevention interventions that are effective for ambulatory people with MS may not work on fulltime wheelchair or scooter users. Thus, in order to inform interventions that have the potential to effectively minimize the frequency and severity of falls among fulltime wheelchair or scooter users with MS, we have undertaken this review to address the following objectives: a) summarize findings regarding influences on falls among fulltime wheelchair and scooter users with MS, as well as associated clinical implications informed by the authors’ clinical experiences and biomechanical principles; b) describe the status and key features of intervention research to date focused on fall prevention for wheelchair and scooter users with MS; and c) present priorities for future research.
Factors associated with falls among wheelchair and scooter users with multiple sclerosis
Among fulltime wheelchair and scooter users living with MS, two studies have examined factors associated with falls.5,6 An international survey-based study5 examined fall prevalence and factors associated with falls among 44 fulltime wheelchair and scooter users with MS with Expanded Disability Status Scale17 (EDSS) scores between 7.0 and 7.5. This cross-sectional study collected data on the number of falls sustained by study participants, location of falls, activities being performed at the time of the fall, concerns about falling, and activity limitations associated with concerns about falling. The majority of participants in the study were female (74.4%) with a mean age of 58.8 ± 12.6 years and used a mobility device an average of 35.6 ± 19.3 hours per week. The most common types of MS reported by participants was primary progressive (n = 19, 43%, previously reported as progressive/relapsing [27%] and primary progressive [16%]). Of the study participants, 75% (n = 33) reported at least one fall in the previous 6 months.5
The second study analyzed the circumstances associated with a fall among wheelchair and scooter users with MS and spinal cord injury through a cross-sectional, mixed methods study.6 Participants self-reported the number of falls experienced in the past 6 months and completed surveys to examine fear of falling and associated activity curtailment. Next, participants described, in detail, the circumstances associated with their most recent fall in the past 6 months. The study included 18 wheelchair users with MS, of which 13 were female and had a mean age of 56.1 ± 9.8 years. Participants lived with MS for an average of 20.1 ± 17.3 years and used a wheelchair for an average of 5.3 ± 6.1 years. Half of the participants with MS used a manual wheelchair and half used a power wheelchair.6
To examine participants’ descriptions of the most recent fall sustained, a thematic analysis was performed.18 To organize the findings, Sung et al.6 proposed a classification system that includes three general categories: action-related fall contributors, the location of falls, and fall attributions (Figure 1). These categories will be used to report on findings from relevant studies, as well as clinical implications.
Action-related fall contributors
Results from both of the above studies indicate that transfers and reaching for objects are commonly associated with falls.5,6 Sung et al. found that transfers were associated with 55% of falls among fulltime wheelchair users.6 This is not surprising given the frequency of transfers fulltime wheelchair and scooter users perform, and the variety (e.g., wheelchair or scooter to/from a bed, car, toilet, tub). Rice et al. also showed that transfers (13.9%) and activities that commonly involve transfers, such as taking a shower (11%) and using the toilet (19.3%), were frequently associated with falls among wheelchair or scooter users with MS.5 In addition, reaching for objects has also been found by Rice et al.5 (13.9%) and Sung et al.6 (6%) to be associated with falls. Findings from both these studies highlight the risk of falling for fulltime wheelchair or scooter users with MS while ambulating short distances. Findings indicate that 14–33% of wheelchair and scooter users with MS reported falling while walking short distances despite using a wheelchair or scooter for the majority of their mobility.5,6
Transfer training, educating persons with MS about reaching beyond the base of support, and rehabilitation/habilitation efforts focusing on safety while ambulating short distances, may help to reduce fall risk among fulltime wheelchair and scooter users with MS. Transfer skill assessment and training must involve observed performance of transfers in a variety of situations, as opposed to reliance on a client’s self-report. Using a validated assessment tool, such as the Transfer Assessment Instrument,19 may help to objectively evaluate the skills. Recognizing that people with MS may use different assistive devices for different needs,20 advice on the best options for assistive devices, and training in use of all prescribed assistive devices (e.g., standard or rolling walkers, quad canes) is warranted. Physical and occupational therapists can work together to build a client’s functional mobility skills, ideally in the natural context.
Individuals with MS can be taught to proactively recognize situations that may result in reaching outside one’s base of support and the associated fall risk, which involves not only displacing center of mass out of the base of support, but also the potential to displace the center of mass outside of the base of support when trying to regain control after an unexpected loss of balance.21,22 Safe reaching practices, from standing or wheelchair level, as well as compensatory strategies (e.g., moving commonly used items) can be incorporated into fall prevention education efforts and are ideally addressed in the context of functional activities (e.g., dressing, bathing).
Brief, but targeted, interviews undertaken with the goal of understanding when and where ambulatory episodes occur support a patient-centered approach to ambulation education and training. Discussions about home accessibility (described in detail later in this paper) may logically follow conversations about when ambulation occurs, since some people with MS may transition to fulltime wheelchair or scooter use before the home is made accessible. A home safety assessment may be warranted to ensure the wheelchair or scooter is compatible with the client's home and can be used in all critical areas. Creating practice opportunities that simulate or (preferably) replicate the situations that require ambulation appear to be vitally important to fall prevention programs. Finally, efforts to improve safety with transfers, reaching, and ambulating short distances may be enhanced by including caregivers in related education efforts. In a qualitative study examining falls self-efficacy among people with MS, “taking personal responsibility to reduce fall risk” emerged as a sub-theme.25 The importance that study participants placed on leading their own fall-prevention efforts serves as a reminder to leave decisions regarding who will, or will not be involved in prevention efforts up to the client, when cognitive status supports such decision making.25
Location of falls
Available evidence indicates that among people with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users, indoor falls are more common than outdoor falls. Rice et al. found that almost 90% of falls among wheelchair and scooters users occur inside of the home; however, the specific location of the fall was not reported.5 Among the falls examined by Sung et al., 25% occur in the bathroom, 17% in the bedroom, 17% in the living room, and 8% in the kitchen. Table 1 provides a breakdown of the fall locations described by Sung et al.6
The high prevalence of indoor falls among wheelchair or scooter users with MS may be driven by the amount of time spent indoors and/or curtailment of activity outside the home. It is important to note that among fulltime wheelchair users, effective home modifications support greater participation in both home and community activities.24 Thus, unmet home modification needs could be contributing to both fall risks in the home and the amount of time spent indoors. Additionally, wheelchair and scooter users with MS perform very complex tasks (e.g., toileting, transferring to/from the shower) in the home, which may increase their risk of falling in distinct locations.
Regarding outdoor falls, Sung et al. found that 17% of falls occur in the garage, and 17% occurred in the garden/yard, as described in Table 1.6 Transferring to or from a wheelchair/scooter to a car can be very challenging as a result of the gap between the device and car, and potentially extreme changes in height. An investigation that examined powered-wheelchair users with varied disabilities, reported falls on the street or sidewalk as the most common outside fall location.16 Falls on the street are highly influenced by environmental factors as well as by the intrinsic fall attributions.16
Findings to date, regarding locations of falls, suggest a variety of clinical implications, ranging from assessment to intervention strategies. With respect to assessment priorities, healthcare providers can initiate conversations with clients to discover where they are spending their time and the activities occurring in those locations. Occupational therapists often perform assessments to determine how clients spend their time using validated instruments, such as the Occupational Questionnaire25 or the National Institutes of Health Activity Record.26 Clinicians can also ask follow-up questions to better understand the client’s rationale for views regarding locations that are, or are not, safe and if the activities undertaken in those locations match personal ability levels.
A number of instruments are available to assess safety in and around the home including the Westmead Home Safety Assessment.27 Also, The Falls Prevention Home and Community Safety Online Workshop (www.fallspreventiononlineworkshops.com.au/) is available to train healthcare providers to conduct a comprehensive home visit to reduce the risk of falls.
Although developed for older community-residing adults, such resources can inform work with people with MS. Both the Westmead Home Safety Assessment and the aforementioned online workshop emphasize that home safety assessments involve more than simply determining the presence or absence of fall hazards in the home. Comprehensive assessments involve assessing interaction between the client’s physical abilities and their exposure to environmental stressors. Given the finding that people with MS who are wheelchair or scooter users often experience outdoor falls occurring at or near the home,6 the importance of including these areas in home safety assessments cannot be overemphasized. Although the effectiveness of comprehensive home safety assessments for people with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users is not known, robust evidence from studies involving older adults indicates that home safety assessment and modification interventions are effective in reducing rate of falls and risk of falling.28,29 Assessing community-based fall hazards can be challenging; however, tools such as the Community Health Environment Checklist,30 can be used to objectively measure the aspects of the physical environment that are important to persons with mobility impairments.
Creating opportunities for clients to practice valued activities in the locations where they typically occur to help the client accurately self-assess abilities and improve safety associated with performance, is clearly an intervention priority. The high prevalence of bathroom falls combined with the potential for injury, due to the (typically) small space and number of hard surfaces, means it is imperative for healthcare providers to build the client’s capacity to safely engage in bathroom-based activities. Ideally, practice opportunities should occur in the client’s home environment, but when this is not possible, clinicians can identify and create an environment which simulates the client’s bathroom as closely as possible. Practicing strategies to manage fall risks in community-based settings is also important and has the potential to foster social integration and participation.
The findings by Rice et al.5 and Sung et al.6 highlight the importance of creating post-fall management plans that are not limited to management of indoor falls. Whether falls occur indoors or outdoors, caregivers may need to be involved in post-fall support to avoid delayed initial recovery or long lies. Clinicians can engage both the person with MS and caregivers to create fall recovery plans that support the safety of both.
The circumstances in which falls occur among fulltime wheelchair and scooter users are multifactorial with various attributions contributing to the complexity. Previous studies show that these factors can be further classified as intrinsic or extrinsic factors.6,31 Intrinsic factors are related to the diagnosis of MS and the impact of fluctuating symptoms.31 Intrinsic risk factors are also related to individual actions, (e.g., distraction or forgetting to engage wheel locks). Extrinsic factors refer to factors related to the environment (e.g., cluttered environment, surface condition), which are closely related to the previously discussed location-related factors, as well as human interference, driving characteristics, or wheelchair malfunction (e.g., equipment failure).16,31
Sung et al. found that 43% of study participants with MS reported muscle weakness or spasticity as an intrinsic risk factor influencing falls, and 15% reported that loss of balance was responsible.6 It was also found that that 21% of wheelchair and scooter users with MS reported surface condition as an extrinsic factor influencing falls.6 It has also been shown, among powered-wheelchair users with various disabilities, including MS, that unfamiliar or inaccessible (e.g., steep inclines, poor lighting, cluttered environments) are common environmental risk factors.16
Like older adults, it appears that people with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users experience falls caused by diverse and interacting risk factors. For example, in a bathroom (location), transferring from a wheelchair to a toilet or tub (activity) can be very challenging for a person with MS who has leg weakness or balance impairments (fall attribution, intrinsic factor).
The wide variation in intrinsic fall risk factors among people with MS makes careful assessment and targeted, individualized interventions a necessity. As potentially important contributors to falls, balance, leg weakness and spasticity warrant careful attention. Fortunately, evidence indicates that people with MS can improve balance and leg strength and reduce or manage spasticity through targeted interventions.32,33 Home exercise programs can be developed for these areas, with the client, in order to maximize adherence and long-term use. Efforts to address fall attributions must include attention to a variety of wheelchair and/or scooter use skills. These skills range from, managing challenging environments (e.g., slick surfaces, steep ramps, high curb cuts, crowds) to building safe habits (e.g., routinely remembering to engage wheel locks).
Wheelchair and/or scooter maintenance is a priority. It is important to provide education about resources such as local Centers for Independent Living and the National Multiple Sclerosis Society that can provide funding for new mobility devices or mobility device repair, and the importance of developing a strong working relationship with wheelchair vendors to assure the wheelchair or scooter continues to meet the individual’s needs. Likewise, the rehabilitation team and/or assistive technology professionals can collaboratively ensure proper seating and positioning is achieved and maintained within the wheelchair or scooter seat.
In general, clinicians have important opportunities to initiate conversations about falls when a person with MS is seen after a fall-related injury, or presents with an MS symptom or situation that has the potential to increase fall risk. These conversations can focus on the diverse contributors to falls and their great potential for modification. Fear of disease progression and dependency are just two of the many reasons that a person with MS may be reluctant to bring up the topic of falls. Highlighting the interprofessional teams’ expertise and eagerness to support the person with MS in his or her efforts to manage fall risks and safely participate in valued activities may help clients engage in honest conversations about this often-difficult subject.
Evidence–based interventions to prevent falls in wheelchair users with multiple sclerosis
The identification of factors influencing falls among people with MS lays the groundwork for the development and testing of targeted interventions designed to reduce fall incidence.34 Several interventions have been developed for ambulatory individuals with the purpose of preventing or reducing fall incidence.35–39 However, a significant limitation was found in the literature regarding falls prevention intervention studies specifically designed for fulltime wheelchair and scooter users with MS.
Only one study was found that reported the feasibility and preliminary results of an intervention focused on improving transfer skills and seated postural control in order to decrease fall frequency and concern about falling in fulltime wheelchair and scooters users with MS.40 Sixteen participants were enrolled with a mean age of 58 years, who had lived with MS for an average of 17 years. The majority of participants were female (69%) and used a manual wheelchair (56.3%). At the start of the intervention, participants reported an average of 1.7 ± 2.7 falls per month. The intervention program consisted of one 45-minute education session, in which individualized transfer education was provided by a trained physical therapist in a research laboratory setting. Participants were also provided with exercises to improve core muscle strength. After the education session, participants were given a manual detailing the transfer education and exercise program for review at home. Participants were asked to perform the exercise program three times per week and review the transfer education once a week at home. After 12 weeks of monitoring, fall frequency significantly decreased (p<0.001, dz=0.26), and transfer quality,41 as well as seated postural control, significantly improved (p=0.01, dz=0.97 and p=0.02, dz=0.83, respectively).40 No significant differences were found regarding concerns about falling, as measured by the Spinal Cord Injury Fall Concerns Scale (p=0.728, dz=0.01). Qualitative results indicated that participants found the education helpful and changed the way transfers were performed. Although the low number of participants limits the generalizability of the findings, the intervention program was found feasible and positively reviewed by study participants. Preliminary results indicate that the education program was effective in decreasing fall frequency among wheelchair and scooter users with MS.
Priorities for future research
Although the amount of scientific interest concerning falls in wheelchair and scooter users with MS is growing, a focused research effort is needed to support the fall prevention needs of this population. Two studies were found that examined influences on fall risk among people with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users; however, prospective studies involving larger, diverse populations are necessary to determine fall risk factors in this population. Multicenter studies will most likely be needed to recruit the number of participants necessary for robust observational studies.
The need exists for evidence-based fall management programs that address physical, behavioral, attitudinal, and environmental fall risk factors appropriate for fulltime wheelchairs or scooters. Randomized trials are needed to assess the efficacy and effectiveness of such interventions. Given the wide range of actions, locations, and attributions that influence fall risk, programs that allow for development and attainment of individualized fall prevention goals appear to be a priority.
Pre-existing programs developed for wheelchair and scooter users may be valuable components of a fall prevention program; however, further evaluation is needed. For example, the Wheelchair Skills Training Program and Test is an excellent resource to both train and evaluate wheelchair skills. The validity of the program is well documented;42–44 however, the effect on wheelchair and scooter users with MS and potential to reduce falls is unclear.45 Over time, trial findings can help to determine the most effective timing for fall prevention programs developed for fulltime wheelchair or scooter users (e.g., when a client is a new versus long-time user), the optimal intervention duration needed to foster long-term benefit, and optimal intervention settings (e.g., home health, community-based programs).
Further research to understand and mitigate fear of falling among those with MS who are fulltime wheelchair or scooter users is needed. Importantly, the Falls Self Efficacy Scale-International, which is frequently used to measure fear of falling in older adults,46 and validated for people with MS,47 cannot be used for fulltime wheelchair users because it includes ambulatory activities. Thus, the development and validation of an effective tool to measure fear of falling for people with MS who use wheeled mobility is needed.
Qualitative research is needed to further understand contextual details that yield realistic and useful fall prevention interventions for this population, as well as the fall prevention needs, preferred strategies, and the role of the caregiver for a person with MS who is a fulltime wheelchair user. In addition, qualitative work to understand when and how people with MS make decisions to move to wheeled mobility, and how these decisions may be related to fall risk, are indicated.
Finally, Finlayson et al.48 poignantly discusses the need to include participation as a long-term outcome in fall prevention intervention research for people with MS. The authors highlight that participation should be “about enabling and empowering individuals with MS to choose and engage in activities that are important and meaningful in their lives while simultaneously reducing risk of falls.”48 The Community Participation Indicators49 or Impact on Participant and Autonomy Questionnaire50 are recommended measures of participation.48 Importantly, qualitative studies are needed to better understand the meaning and role of participation in the context of fall prevention efforts involving people with MS who use wheelchairs or scooters.
This review highlights the diverse influences on fall risk for fulltime wheelchair or scooter users with MS, as well as the need for well-designed studies to evaluate comprehensive fall prevention programs developed specifically for this population. In the absence of clear practice directives, clinicians are advised to utilize evidence-informed strategies as well as the expertise of the interprofessional team to best support fulltime wheelchair or scooter users with MS in their efforts to prevent falls. MS and fall prevention researchers have a number of unique opportunities to make important contributions to the development of fall prevention resources for this vulnerable population.